Always enjoyed the scent of bay rum. The barber I was going to before I moved used Stephens. Smelled nice. Not as clovey as my Pinaud VIBR. But it didn't last very long on me. After I use up my Pinaud VIBR I may switch up and try one of the others that have been mentioned. For cologne I purchased Gilbert Henry's bay rum. I enjoy it and the scent lasts for quite a while on me.
I just got a bottle of Gilbert Henry and I like it. Some cloves and bay but later it was a little citrus and maybe light vanilla? Really nice.