Which one is the best? Tell me. Now. I kid, I kid. But really, I am looking for a recommendation. Is there a difference between a cologne and an afterhsave? I don't like the smell of most colognes. In seeking a bay rum, I would be looking for something to use as an effective aftershave, something soothing. A pleasant smell is, of course, desirable. I don't want a list of ingredients that reads like a package of Twizzlers. I prefer no dyes. Any insight is appreciated.