I'm looking for a subtle lime/citrus aftershave

I see many Pinaud products in the beauty supply shops near by. This one nobody stocks. I keep asking for them to order it. One day I'll just breakdown and get Amazon to ship it.
The scent of Lime Sec is like lime candy, sweet? Good to hear it's like other Pinaud's - all day staying power.

 

Pinaud Lime Musk is also great. I picked up Avon Island Lime off ebay, like it lots.

 

Captains Choice Lime is very subtle and only last about 30 minutes. It is about $18.00 for four ounces. A little goes a long way.

Dave

 

Gabels is a very mild lime aftershave and inexpensive.

 

It smells sweeter than lime juice, but I would not call it "candy sweet". Also the bottle is huge. I think one would be enough to last years unless you use it every day.

 

I like that about Pinaud; big bottles, low prices, strong long lasting scents. Good business model.

 

TSD Lime splash is divine, and actually smells like real lime. I need to get some more.

 

I have recently started a quest for the best lime aftershave. I use the traditional aftershaves made by Clubman/Pinaud and Master Wellcomb, along with Old Spice Original (imported from India). My favorites are Master Spice, Master Blue, and Clubman Virgin Island Bay Rum. I have purchased a few lime aftershaves so far: Captain's Choice Lime and Booster's Iced Lime and have ordered but not yet received Royall Lime along with Royall Mandarin (to add some orange to the mix). I have yet to try to Gabel's Drops of Lime, Clubman Lime Sec, and Colonel Conk's Lime (I have a requested a sample, so we will see if I get a reply). When I was a child, I remember my dad having gift sets of Aqua Velva and English Leather that had lime among the scents (I think he had the Mennen set too with Dry Lime, but I don't recall--I saw it on Ebay). I am not too impressed with the Captain's Lime as it doesn't have much of a lime scent, and what it does have is gone in a flash. Boosters starts off smelling like lime, but then another scent comes in, and I am not a fan. My favorite of all-time is Guerlain Eau de Fleurs de Cedrat, which has a light, refreshing citrus scent, but it has gotten mighty pricey over the years. Does anyone have any other suggestions?

 

Razorock essential lime aftershave is very nice. it was given to me, but i like it allot.

 

Crabtree & Evelyn West Indian Lime cologne is superb

 

There's #74 Victorian Lime or the Eton College