OK, if right now you had to pick your favorite soap of all of them you've used up to now and you could only pick one. Which would it be? For me I think TSD Magnolia would be top of my list, it's ridiculously easy to lather and smells very nice first thing in the morning. The quality of the lather is also outstanding.
I have only used the Tabac, Wilkinson Sword (soft soap) , Erasmic (soft soap) , Cella (soft soap) and Wilkinson Sword shave stick out of my collection. I like the Erasmic, but it is a real cheapie and is soft. The Tabac was great too and is the only hard triple milled soap I have tried.
Do I have to pick one?? Ok, ok.....would have to say Cella. It's just wonderful but a close second would be Kell's Original in Juniper & Sage
Godrej Shaving Round - I like the classic fragrance, it lathers instantly and very well and hey it costs less than pennies