So far the best for me has been TOBS almond cream with HBS Bay Rum. I know it sounds weird but it smell so good and works great. Whats yours?
IK SS / TOBS Rose SC; not a true "Superlather" I guess. Load the brush with soap like normal, small dollop of cream in the bowl = :1respect
Any Lime soap w/ CO Bigelow/Proraso. Any Almond soap w/ The Body Shop Cream (old formula). I have also found KMF cream to jazz up pretty much any underperforming soap. Scent doesn't matter as they are extremely light and fade quickly.
I have to go with VDH infused with peppermint EO and KMF Cool Mint. My after shave when I use this is always Nivea balm that has also been infused with peppermint EO. Chillin'!
I perfer Osage when I shave my head but some Aqua Velva mixed with Anherb after that shave is pretty good.
I am guessing that you can't feel most of your head and face for a good 3 hours after using that menthol kick.