C&E Sienna balm was my first, when I stared just a few weeks ago. It has worked flawlessly and I love the scent - YMMV on scent. But make sure you like it, because it is a bit stronger than the Nivea and lingers a good while. Not so strong that cologne will clash however. It is expensive, yes. $30 retail, $23.97 on sale. But the Buy Two, get the 3rd free, makes it about $20/bottle. Still not cheap, but I probably will no longer use it EVERY day. No alcohol, but my skin is normal to slightly dry, so I don't "need" the alcohol. I use Thayer's WH every so often before the Sienna and all is well. I think Sienna is especially good for the winter and am told it does contain its own witch hazel. Nivea Sensitive After Shave Balm. White bottle, white lid. I get mine at Walmart or RiteAid, Wally is $1.15 cheaper, though Riteaid has had the "free" trial size attached. For $5.54, I can't imagine a better product exists, as my 6 bottles in storage will attest. It leaves the skin very smooth with a good clean scent. Happy shaves to you
Hey Joseywales don't know if these are there or not, but if not you should go do a mini write up of these in the reviews section under skin care or maybe aftershave. That way others can benefit from your experience. This thread will be lost to time eventually. You can also link to this thread in your review for discussion.