I've tried all of these. They are all very good but the IK is my current favorite soap. PdP being next on your list - it has a terrific scent but the shave is not QUITE up to IK. IK just rocks! Ken
I voted pre de provence....it sounds better coming off the tongue than the other soaps.....oops didn't mean to throw in a taste reference there.(the queen will get it)
My vote is for the Valobra shaving stick. However, I've heard rumors that AOS soaps are made by valobra and are very very close in formula to the Valobra shave stick. So if you want the benefit of valobra, but with a different scent, AOS might be the ticket.
I guess I have to add another vote for Valobra. The stick is not as good value as the soft-soap but it works better in my opinion.
JoAnna was kind enough to gift me some of the Valobra soft (almond) soap but I am still anxious to try the Shave stick. Need to trade off some goods 1st Anybuddy got an extra stick they want to trade ??