Pinaud Clubman VS Aqua Velva Ice Blue VS Skin Bracer

If you had the option to choose only one option out of the three what would you choose?

Pinaud Clubman




Aqua Velva Ice Blue





Skin Bracer

 

Dang, 4am I'm still awake to answer this. Hard choice... I'll take skin bracer for the vote but I love all three equally. It depends on my mood. I guess skin bracer is on my mind today so it gets my vote. Really all three are equal in my mind, you really need to own them all plus a few others, just the basics really.

 

Double dang, I just awoke, when you decided to post you comment @Rockclimber . Pinaud all the way, for me.

 

Pinaud, the epitome of what an aftershave should be. It'll be interesting to see how the voting shakes out. I'm betting pinaud wins 4-1..

 

I used Pinaud twice. The stink got me so sick that i almost vomited! I dumped that cat pee down the drain as fast as I could and didn't look back!

I do love Aqua Velva and Skin Bracer!

 

I can't vote on this one because I use all 3-it depends on the seasons. But all 3 are great.

 

with a goalie mask like that for your avatar, you'll most probably win.

 

I went with Skin Bracer. I've only used Clubman once. I like Aqua Velva but reach for Skin Bracer more.

 

Now you knuckleheads are just out to prove me wrong

 

But you said Clubman is the epitome of what an aftershave should be. If you'll pardon the double negatory, that ain't wrong .

 

Pinaud

 

Toss up between AV and SB for me. Gun to the head though, I guess I'm an Aqua Velva man.

 

It would be nice if I could get a whiff of Pinaud but they all come with a plastic seal over the cap as in your photo, and I don't feel like buying an entire bottle just to get a quick smell.

 

I'm gonna have to go with Aqua Velva.

 

Read the many(and I do mean MANY) 5-star revews of Pinaud on Amazon.

 

I did exactly that. Almost everyone just says you'll smell like a man. Some say you'll smell like an old man. One guy says you'll smell like you just came out of a barbershop.

I've been to countless barbershops and they all smelled differently. I still don't understand what the barbershop smell is and I probably won't ever know what this aftershave smells like unless I get a chance to smell it myself.

 

Oh, I understand...testing is best of course. I do hope you get a chance to soon.

 

My wife goes all weak in the knees when she smells Pinaud on me.

 

I'm getting ready to do a Clubman package order soon-trying out those new shave creams(well, one is a cream, the other a shave soap-both come in tubs). Both apparently have the Vanilla scent, but I'll use my regular-scent Clubman aftershave to "wash it away"(the Vanilla, that is). There are plenty of positive Amazon reviews on the Vanilla, though.

 

I haven't posted in a bit, but after seeing that Pinaud Clubman might lose a poll, I had to chime in.