Please recommend an AS splash

About to finish up my bottle of Old Spice and am looking for something else to try that's good...

Other than AV, because my gf hates the scent.

So what would you guys recommend as a good/best splash? Mentholated would be a plus, but not necessary. Thanks!

BTW I plan on getting it from either QED or Classicshaving...

 

My vote goes to Master's Bay Rum. Some women do not like subtle scents and Acqua Velva is rather subtle. Master's Bay Rum is anything but subtle. It's my personal favorite.

For other input I would recommend that you read the reviews section of these forums.

 

QED or ClassicShaving?

Low Priced:
Pinaud Products (only at ClassicShaving)

High Priced:
Pashana aftershave, as well as Musgo Real aftershave both are carried at those vendors.


Note: My recommendations would be MUCH, MUCH different if I wasn't relegated to those two vendors

 

Skin Bracer.

Plenty of Menthol.

 

Yeah, that would be a no brainer if you're looking for something local.

 

Your rec, Pinaud Clubman is local. Just no menthol.

 

Ok Joe, well let's loosen up my vendor requirements...what then? I kinda want something in one of those fancy coke bottles.

 

Check out this link here:

http://www.appletonbarbersupply.com...reen=CTGY&Store_Code=ABS&Category_Code=AFTE01

Don't forget to hit the "next" button at the bottom (there's three pages worth of splash)

After you get done browsing there, I can show more

 

DO IT~!

 

Bottom line, of all the aftershaves out there (I don't know the # I've tried, but its probably near 100).....here's a few of my favorites:

De Vergulde Hand Aftershave Spray
Brut Aftershave Splash
Italian FLOID Aftershave Splash
St. John's Bay Rum Aftershave Splash
Brutal Aftershave Splash - Classic
Aubrey Organics "Spice Island" (bay rum) Aftershave Splash
Stephan's Bay Rum Aftershave Splash
Stephan's 320 Astringent Lotion
Stephan's Alpine Menthol Aftershave Splash
Lustray Menthol Aftershave Splash
Aqua Velva Classic Ice Blue Aftershave Splash
Booster Mosswood Aftershave Splash
Aqua Velva Ice Blue Splash (Italian)
Swiss Pitralon Aftershave Splash
Spanish Aqua Velva Aftershave Splash
Spanish Floid Aftershave Splash
Aqua Velva Original Sport Aftershave Splash
Alt-Innsbruck Aftershave Splash
Tuff Rasierwasser (Aftershave Splash)


Those containing higher levels of menthol in bold

 

SHOW US

 

I KNEW i shouldve picked up the Lucky Tiger stuff when i was back home. Cant find it here at all

 

Joe...how do you like the Stephan's stuff. I was at a store back home.that had alot of their stuff.....but smelling it didnt do it for me.

 

Their aftershaves are great.

• I highly recommend the Alpine Menthol. REVIEW
• The bay rum is the finest of the "cheap" bay rum splashes I have tried (so far). REVIEW

 

I thought you said Gabriels is?

oh well, collect them all! ::

You need to get some Superior 70.

 

Read the review!

 

Thanks. Wow, quite a bit to absorb!! Unfortunately the appleton supply doesn't have any of the FLOIDs or Stephan Alpine. I'll definitely keep trying vendors though. Thanks Joe :drool

 

Appleton used to carry the Alpine Menthol (That's where I got mine)....but you're right it looks like its gone

 

I'll find it elsewhere, thanks Joe. What is the scent like?