I used my sample of the Tobacco Leaf bath soap this morning. I LOVE it. I hope they keep it and come out with the full line up. My favorites remain: Gentleman, Executive Man, Margaritas in the Arctic, Ozark Mountain.
Speick trifecta is nice. DR Harris Sandalwood, although it is technically a milk and not a 'balm' per se.
Wholly Kaw offers soaps, balms, and AS. I ama big Stirling fan, and the Wholly Kaw soaps are on par with with these in terms of performance.
Interestingly, for me, Gentleman came in second behind Sandpiper with my first sample set, I should have given that one(Gentleman)another try with my current set, which includes Xecutive Man again. I predict a neck-and-neck between Xecutive Man and Gatlinburg this time.