Top five, huh? Good question. 1. Fine Barber Blue (not sure how to classify this one) 2. Citrus 3. Spicy/Citrus 4. Barbershop (Crown Shaving, Clubman) 5. Woody (D.R. Harris Windsor) I love menthol, so if for some reason I pick up an AS without it, I'll add menthol, like D.R. Harris Arlington. It needed that extra boost.