What's Your Favorite Menthol?

The recent thread on Arko creams got me thinking about menthol. I've been poking around, and figured I'd see if we can't compile a list of great menthol products. Some of my favorites:
-Stirling Glacials and Iced/On the Rocks
-Proraso green
-Aqua Velva Blue
So, what else deserves a shot? Anything from mild to wild, as long as it's got menthol! (I'm looking at you, @Yehuda D!)

 

Proraso White has a nice but mild menthol effect. Also Skin Bracer and Barbasol Pacific Rush aftershaves have a nice menthol kick to them. The Stirling Glacials are of course top notch!

 

Osage Rub
TSD Iced Subzero
M Bomb from TSD
Ingram Shave Cream

 

What a hard question to answer but I'll give it the old college try!

Mild menthol: Nothing - just kidding because there's,

Soaps:

Proraso White
Mickey Lee Paradise Frost

Creams:

Lord Emofresh
Cerrus (now discontinued)
Hamol (from Syria)

Aftershaves:

Razorock One X
Razorock Don Donato
Italian Barber Amici

Medium menthol - let's see,

Soaps:

Proraso Green
OSP Grapefruit Menthol

Creams:

Egyptian Ingram
Arko Ice Mint
Gada Cool Mint
Top Ten Sensitive
Derbylux
Lea Classic

Aftershaves:

Mennen Skin Bracer
Aqua Velva Ice Blue
Floid Classic
Reef Point Fougere Santal

Strong menthol - now it's getting interesting,

Soaps:

TSD Iced Subzero
Stirling MITA
Stirling Black Ice
Stirling Gin & Tonic on the Rocks
Stirling Frozen Tundra
First Canadian Polar Vortex
Soap Smooth Frozen Cranberry
Krampert's Frostbite

Creams:

Palmolive Menthol
Gillette Menthol
Lea Menthol

Aftershaves:

Osage Rub
Alcolado Glacial

Mega strong menthol - now you're talking my language,

Soaps:

Stirling Glacial Eskimo Tuxedo
Stirling Glacial Obsidian
Stirling Glacial MITA
Stirling Glacial Spearmint
Stirling Glacial Wintergreen

Creams: N/A

Aftershaves:

B&M Arctique
Stirling Glacial Wintergreen Witch Hazel
Stirling Lemon Chill Witch Hazel
Fine Snake Bite

That's the best I can do!

 

Trying not to double up anything. I'll add Stirling Iced Pineapple as a favorite, and Cold River Soap Works Limenthol. Barbasol Brisk and Fine Snakebite, Platinum and American Blend. I hear Chiseled Face Cryogen is a beast.

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

 

I've had it.(cryogen) It'll literally make your eyes water. I've thought about buying a tub, only because it's been over a year. We all know how pain fades with time.

 

Keith, the Glacial soaps are now as killer-cold as Cryogen. Can they ever give you "tears of joy" if you love menthol.

 

My absolute favorite....just alcohol, water & menthol. 'Burn & Quench' after shaving tonic.

 

That's been on my wish list for quite awhile... I'll break down and order a bottle some day!

 

Soap: Catie's Bubbles "Sunrise". Has a little shot on the second pass.
Cream: Proraso Green and it's cousin C O Bigelow.

 

I'm on my 4th or 5th bottle. The stuff will definitely wake you up!
I do enjoy the 'snake oil' copy on bottle: "Guaranteed tenfold increase in vigor, bravery, and pluck. The weak become strong, the lazy become lively and the meek become leaders of men.'

 

Kevin, that slogan alone puts it on my must have list

 

I think the only thing I have with Menthol in it is the green Proraso.

 

Is there a SEM with menthol? If so I want to try it!

Sent from my SM-G930P using Tapatalk

 

Stirling Frozen Tundra
Krampert's Frostbite
Chiseled Face Cryogen (Use with caution. This stuff will make your eyes water and, if you are feeling brave, slap on some Osage Rub AS. Not for the weak of heart.)

 

Don't forget the warning: "Keep away from women and children."

 

Proraso Green (I use the cream in the tube) for a mild to medium strength when you aren't after a major shot of menthol or fragrance. Just a good shave cream. The aftershave has a nice face feel, but the menthol is mild, and it has a classic but fleeting scent.
Stirling's Margaritas in the Arctic (MITA) is my favorite right now. Strong menthol and strong lime scent. I will mix up a little extra intentionally so I can rub some on my face after I'm done shaving. That's when it feels really cold. I haven't tried the Glacial MITA which is supposed to have almost three times the menthol as the standard version. The standard version gives a nice satisfying menthol cooling effect, so I'm not sure I need the Glacial, but I would give it a shot in a sample size. The MITA aftershave is also outstanding.

 

I think you missed a few.

 

Stirling orange chill and iced pineapple.

 

Can't go wrong with the Stirling Glacial line but I'm more into mild menthol and for that I like Prorasso for cream and Skin Bracer or Floid Vigoroso for aftershave. Barbasol Pacific Rush was good but has been discontinued.
Shaving Yeti is another high menthol option & is Myrsol Formula K.