It took about 2 years but I finally found my perfect menthol combo, which is: Neutrogena Invigorating Face Wash Jack Black Beard Lube The Shave Den Iced Sub Zero Soap Osage Rub Proraso Liquid After Shave What is your perfect combo?
Vitos Pre Shave Palmolive Menthol (Italian cream) Vitos ICE aftershave That my favorite combination so far. The ICE aftershave is a lot colder then their Menthol version.
I knew this would be impossible for you Jeff. How about a David Letterman style Top Ten list of menthol products?
I still don't know the answer for during the shave, but for aftershave it's clearly: Liquid Candy Cane Snowflakes (AKA TSD Iced Peppermint)
I have almost all of my stuff boosted, nearly any combo works. I've found though that my overzealous mentholations, while having their place, are not my favorite products necessarily.
I'm afraid I'm in the same boat,I haven't found a menthol I didn't like and I dont care if it's 40 below,it's all good,I'll use 444 or M-Bomb or both.