Which Old Spice Soap should I use 1970's or 1950's?

I was lucky enough to win two mug n' soap combinations on the Bay today - one from the 70's, and one from the 50's.

These are the items:

1970's Old Spice soap

1950's Old Spice soap and aftershave

So my question is... which one should I use, and which one should I save for my boy? Do you think the 40's stuff will be any good any more? Is the older mug better somehow? Is the older SOAP better somehow?

Thanks for your experience and suggestions, fellas.

 

As far as I know the formulas should be the same. The only difference is the strength of the scent between the two. The 70's puck should have more scent left to it.

Enjoy them!

 

lucky guy...I wish I could have your same dilemma with the soaps!

 

I haven't used the 70s stuff but I have a puck of 1940s OS and it is fantastic. I think you should keep the 50s puck and save the 70s one for your son.

 

neat stuff Greg! Not that it helps any, but I have the same mug from the 70's set myself! It's a good one...very heavy...