Your Top 5 Bay Rums

Discussion in 'Scents' started by Orgoglio italianO, Mar 10, 2014.

  1. HolyRollah

    HolyRollah BaconLord Staff Member

    ...Or as close as a consensus as we're possibly able to get when it comes to the subjective minefield of fragrances.
  2. Derhey

    Derhey Well-Known Member

  3. HolyRollah

    HolyRollah BaconLord Staff Member

    Good choice on the sampler pack! When it does arrive—before applying any to your face—be certain to SHAKE the bottle well to ensure a through mix. Ogallala seems more prone to separating than other AS compositions. Good stuff, however...
    Paul Turner likes this.
  4. Derhey

    Derhey Well-Known Member

    Thanks for the warning! So many products that I want to try!
  5. Norseman

    Norseman misunderstood Dark Lord of the Sith

  6. Hodge

    Hodge Well-Known Member

    For the guys not liking the overpowering cloves/spicyness of the ones listed above, Lucky Tiger might be worth a try. It is quite nice but not overpowering at all. TOBS is similar but more expensive. Me, I'm really starting to like the burn of the clovey/spicey ones (CC and HTGAM).
  7. CyanideMetal

    CyanideMetal Wild and crazy guy

    If you've never tried Meehan's BR, you should. Made in California in small batches by the family.
    Paul Turner likes this.
  8. maliboy67

    maliboy67 Well-Known Member

    I took a chance and picked up a bottle of Ogallala bay rum, sage and cedar. I really love the scent, the only beef I have is it doesn't last very long. Great splash with a nice tingle.
  9. Leo501

    Leo501 Well-Known Member

    Thread Revival

    1- Ogalla Bay Rum (& Sandalwood)
    2- Clubman VIBR

    The only 2 I've used. VIBR + my Covid mask leaves me smelling like a giant stick of Dentyne gum, which I enjoyed.

    Looking forward to trying Captain's Choice and St John's. BR has such varied interpretations.
    Jorvaljr and Ijustmissedthe50s like this.
  10. PLANofMAN

    PLANofMAN Paperboy

    Article Team
    I really like Derby City Chop Shop's Winter Reserve. It's one of the more conservative interpretations of Bay Rum. It's also rather expensive.

    It's on the opposite end of the spectrum from Oogalla bay rum. Mellow rather than punchy. It also uses bourbon and witch hazel as a base, which contributes to the mellow vanilla overtones in it.

    Edit: Price is somewhat accounted for in that it comes in 7.4 fl. oz., rather than the 4.2 fl. oz of most competitors. Shipping, is as always, painfully expensive. I buy 2 bottles at a time to offset some of the shipping costs.
    Last edited: Mar 2, 2022
    Paul Turner likes this.
  11. The situational shaver

    The situational shaver Well-Known Member

    High humidity- Dominica Medium humidity- Gabels Low humidity- Masters

    High humidity- V.I.B.R. Medium humidity- Col. Conks. Low humidity- Capt. Choice
    Paul Turner likes this.
  12. cpool222

    cpool222 Well-Known Member

    Of the ones I've tried, I like Clubman , Col. Conk and Captain's Choice the best. Also like another one, name escapes me, but it's too expensive for me to recommend. These three are affordable and great IMO
    Ijustmissedthe50s likes this.
  13. SterFry

    SterFry Active Member

    Pinaud VIBR
    Captains Choice Co9T
    Captains Choice Bay Rum
    Colonel Conk Bay Rum
    Barrister and Mann Bay Rum.

    No particular order
  14. Primotenore

    Primotenore missed opera tunity

    Article Team
    Meehan Bay Rhum
    Ogallala Limes & Peppercorns
    C.O. Bigelow
    Burt's Bees
  15. Ijustmissedthe50s

    Ijustmissedthe50s The Warnee

    Anything by Ogallala
    My home made stuff
    Pinaud VIBR
    Vintage Lustray
    Paul Turner and Jorvaljr like this.
  16. Paul Turner

    Paul Turner outside the quote(s) now

    Joseph, I always knew you were a "Meehan Man".
  17. Paul Turner

    Paul Turner outside the quote(s) now

    Is it Stephan's?
  18. Paul Turner

    Paul Turner outside the quote(s) now

    You don't like Bay Rum in general, Norseman?
  19. Hammer8

    Hammer8 Well-Known Member

    Captain’s Choice Bay Rum or Cat O’ Nine Tails, or Ogallala.
    Ijustmissedthe50s likes this.
  20. Kilgore Trout

    Kilgore Trout The Smart Bunny

    I guess it depends on the situation.
    Ijustmissedthe50s likes this.

Share This Page