These days Stirling MITA (1), Captain's Co9T (2), and Proraso Green (3). One and 2 may flip in the winter. This would be my list for scents. These also work well. I won't keep an AS around if it doesn't make my face feel good after a shave: WSP Sandalwood (long lasting scent, pure Sandalwood), Stirling Executive Man (get it with menthol), Co9T, MITA.
I love the Stirling PSB except it is rather thick. I have to apply it to a wet face to be able to spread it out. Funny thing is, this makes for a more frugal product. No extra water is shipped and it makes it last much longer. Scents are always awesome. I use about a pea amount for my entire face. Nivea Sensitive ASB, is also excellent and easy to find locally. Only downside is I need about a nickel sized amount. I find both to be top notch.
3 months ago I said Barrister's Reserve. Couldn't pick between Cool or Spice. For performance I'd now add Chatillon Lux to that list. Couldn't pick as best from either brand. Scent only, I'd give Stirling Gentleman a nod as well. SWMBO wouldn't put it quite so high on the list... For her it is Reserve Spice or Stirling Barbershop.
Even though I don't shave much these days, I still rotate between Aqua Velva Ice Blue and Mennen Skin Bracer.
I used that last night for the first time. My mother-in-law brought me a bottle from Germany. Very nice scent.
Top aftershave well it depends on diffrent things, or what kind of mood youre in. English Leather Irish moos Flóid blue and amber Figaro Razorock..xxx, tuscan oud,zippino Proraso red and green Pitrolon classic
Wow...this is a tough one! I've changed my mind quite a few times lol. I know I'd probably respond with something different by next month lol. As for right now though, I'd say I wouldn't want to be without Lucky Tiger Toner or Lanman and Murray Florida Water. That's one, right? The post specifies one doesn't it? I did just reply with one, didn't I?
Florida Frost is something I mix up of three parts Florida Water and one part Osage Rub. Nice cooling flowering citrus without too much menthol scent. Steel Blue is 50/50 AV and Florida Water.