I would give QED or Mamabear's a try. I think QED is a slightly better shaving soap, but Mamabear's has some great scents, and the prices are really competitive. With their range of scents, I'm sure you'll find something you like. You mentioned you didn't like the English Fern. If you want to trade or sell your EF, PM me and I'll see if we can work something out! I have plenty of Mamabears that I'd be willing to trade.