The Stirling Exchange

Discussion in 'Shave Soaps' started by PickledNorthern, Nov 5, 2016.

  1. gcconspiracy

    gcconspiracy Well-Known Member

    Yeah, if I HAD to pick a favorite it would probably be Executive Man, but it’s so close!

    Yeah, the fact that Executive Man is his best seller was part of the reason that I chased Aventus down in the first place... I can see why it is #1!

    I plan to leave reviews, but I’d like to get a few more shaves under my belt with each scent before I do that.
     
  2. blondblue

    blondblue Well-Known Member

    That's wise. I'm behind on my reviews for a couple shave soaps and an A.S. Here's something funny-I thought I didn't do a review for Sandpiper shave soap, so I got to the page, and in fact, I HAD done one!
     
  3. Gnomeo0228

    Gnomeo0228 Well-Known Member

    Happy Father's Day all my wetshaving brothers!
     
  4. Gnomeo0228

    Gnomeo0228 Well-Known Member

    This made me happy lol
     
  5. blondblue

    blondblue Well-Known Member

    Leroy, at the 3:00 mark of your Varen video, I thought you were going to walk right through my computer and into my apartment. :). A little adjusting needed, perhaps?
     
  6. Gnomeo0228

    Gnomeo0228 Well-Known Member

    ahahaha! I didn't want to waste ANY of the bloom water hehe
     
  7. blondblue

    blondblue Well-Known Member

    Leroy, as you know, my bathroom is too small for a video. This would be me doing one:

    Me-Awwwright, all set to do a shave for you guys, using Central Texas Soaps and........HEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
     
  8. gcconspiracy

    gcconspiracy Well-Known Member

    Glad to hear it!
     
  9. Gnomeo0228

    Gnomeo0228 Well-Known Member

    hahahaha!
     
  10. Latherin’ Luddite

    Latherin’ Luddite Well-Known Member

    Well the weather literally changed overnight. Fathers Day was cool and partly cloudy which made Sterling Spice the perfect shave soap and splash, since Old Spice was a very traditional gift for many dads. I’m very happy with the scent, and the splash hangs on like an EDT. I still had nice mellow mid and base notes 12 hrs later.

    THEN the heat hit! So I finally cycled my current 10 soaps for 10 hot weather soaps, and G&T on the rocks held the honors of kicking off the heatwave. It was a great as always. Next up will be MITA.
    Happy heat everyone.
     
  11. timabababaluka

    timabababaluka No exceptions. Except.....

    Very nice! Super hot here as well--thank heavens for Frost Drops and ice water :D
     
  12. gcconspiracy

    gcconspiracy Well-Known Member

    Well, I gave Barbershop a second chance and unfortunately I don’t think there will be a third. Again it smelled amazing off the puck, but once lathered it took on the same offputting (to me) odour. Not only that, but by the end of the shave I felt a burning on my face, around my nose, and even in my throat when a touch got in my mouth . It’s an absolute shame, as when I first smelled the puck I was sure that it would become a long-time favorite of mine, but it seems clear that will not be the case.

    On a brighter note, I decided to shave with Gentleman tonight. To my nose the scent of Gentleman and Barbershop are similar off the puck (Gentleman just smells like grown-up Barbershop to my nose), so I thought it would be a good redemption shave after yesterday’s foray with Barbershop. The scent was stellar, the shave was beautiful, and Gentleman is seriously growing on me... it just may be the Barbershop that I was looking for!
     
  13. chevyguy

    chevyguy Well-Known Member

    Stirling Samples are the best.

    Clayton

    Sent from my SM-A705U using Tapatalk
     
  14. chevyguy

    chevyguy Well-Known Member

    Try a sample of Stirling's Aftershave Splash. It has witch hazel in it and I find that my sometimes easily irritated skin finds it very soothing. I use it daily, it's food for the skin.

    Clayton

    Sent from my SM-A705U using Tapatalk
     
  15. Gnomeo0228

    Gnomeo0228 Well-Known Member

    Oh man, sorry to hear about that. Scents are such a YMMV thing with this hobby, maybe more than any other hobby lol
     
  16. timabababaluka

    timabababaluka No exceptions. Except.....

    I'm not the hugest fan of powder-like scents, so I avoided Barbershop.

    My initial experience with Gentleman was the exact opposite. One whiff, and I thought to myself, "Good heavens... what have I done?" I hid it deep in a little used drawer so my wife wouldn't stumble across it. Eventually, I lathered up that horrid, horrid puck... and was amazed. Man, do I love Gentleman! The Missus thinks it smells like dill (am I crazy for thinking that's crazy?), so it wasn't a repurchase, but it was an enjoyable run. I'd be using it even now, otherwise.
     
  17. blondblue

    blondblue Well-Known Member

    I have Gentleman aftershave. It's NIIICE.
     
    Trigger, john zeiger, ezlovan and 3 others like this.
  18. blondblue

    blondblue Well-Known Member

    Ehhh LADIES and uh GENTLEMEN:

    The selected date for the next Stoylin Tony Awards Nominations day will be August 26. Yeah, I know....a long wait, but I wanted to do it on a special event day. Being the animal-lover I am, that date is National Dog Day. August is a quiet month for special event dates. Anyway....see ya on August 26!
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Jun 26, 2020
  19. blondblue

    blondblue Well-Known Member

    I'm still working with my "official" comment on Blood on Steel.
     
  20. gcconspiracy

    gcconspiracy Well-Known Member

    Yeah, it was a bummer, but as you say - YMMV! Fortunately Stirling makes more than enough scents, so we can all find the ones that work for us!

    I think Gentleman is quickly becoming a favorite out of my order of samples (alongside Executive Man, Mountain Man, Sharp Dressed Man, and Sandpiper!). I have to say though, I don't smell dill of any sort from Gentleman... Either way, I'm glad you ended up enjoying Gentleman while it lasted!
     

Share This Page