Matt,
Molten has Lemon, Bergamot, Birch Tar, Acacia, Cistus labdanum, Malt, Vanilla, and Oak and to my nose reminds me of Henry Weinhard's Root Beer and William Neumann’s famous Old-Fashioned Soda but deeper scent profile.
Small Batch Shave Tonic IMHO goes well with anything sweet warm, spicy, and even coffee scents. Ingredients are: Kentucky Bourbon, Vanilla, Vetiver, Pimenta Racemosa, Blood Orange, Cinnamon, Cloves, Allspice, Rosewood, Rosewater,, Alcohol, Aloe Vera, Witch Hazel, Glycerin. To my nose, I pick up honey/vanilla first with the Bourbon I get light smoked aroma with a touch of orange spice. So long story short, the closest aroma to Root Beer/Sasparilla that I have to match Molten. Now having said all that, as noted many times over the years, I have a lifelong sinus issue so my sense of smell is quite different from others such as yourself and reason I do not comment or do reviews. What you pickup from Molten is probably different that what I pickup.
Click to expand...