1. Sudsy Soapery, Tabac both strongly scented and long lasting.

    Be careful with your aftershave pairing :D
  2. Stirling Soap Co. has lots of choices and best of all if you like to try a few with out commitment to a whole puck go for the samples. As for matching with AS, they carry them as well.
    Yehuda D, Stu929 and Tiredricefarmer like this.
  3. Ohhhhhhhhh, I don't know if I'd call Stirling a croap, my brother! (But I do agree the Electric Sheep is a strong, but NICE scent!) ;)
  4. So true! Wife and I picked up like 8 or 9 samples and have loved them all expect one. Funny thing is I knew I probably wouldn't like it but it had such a good reputation I wanted to be sure. If you happen to have an old spice mug the Stirling samples fit perfectly in them.

    I enjoy sandpiper, ben franklin, mountain man and Executive Man. Im sure there are others but theses are ones Ive tried and enjoyed. Executive man is my everyday shave soap and I have the matching afyer shave.

    Sent from my SM-G930P using Tapatalk
  5. Which one didn't you like? Mine was Stirling Bay Rum. I find it harder to find one I don't like. :D
  6. Well, my Electric Sheep, and Scots Pine Sheep are not hard puck soaps, and they are not creams... What else do I call them if not croaps???
    Yehuda D likes this.
  7. I don't know what to say! lolll
  8. That it is. My Monday shave was with Barbershop and maybe today's as well. I never know which soap I'll use until I stand there in front of the entire inventory.
    RyX and blondblue like this.
  9. Stirling enough said. ;) :)
    blondblue likes this.
  10. While I agree that Stirling isn't a super hard soap, I don't think it's soft enough to be considered a croap either. In my experience, the sample sizes are much softer. The full size tubs I got are lumpy on top from the way they're filled, but I can't press a finger in them the way I can with something like Cello.

  11. Stirling soaps
    Catie's bubbles
    Barrister and Mann
    L & L grooming


    In that order, too
  12. Agree - Stirling is not a croap. It is not as hard as some such as Tabac and the various Fine soaps but certainly harder than Cella and the Proraso type soaps. I did a test on a new tub of Stirling Barbershop. I weighed the tub before using it for the first time. After ten shaves with full brush loading and bowl lathering - I weighed it again. I calculate that I will get just over 60 shaves from that one tub. That's pretty good.
    Enrico likes this.
  13. ARKO.
  14. Dr. Jon's Aphrodite is really strong. Lasts all day too.

    Sent from my SM-N920V using Tapatalk
  15. Perhaps a good move by Doc Ezlovan to introduce it as an aftershave, too.
    PickledNorthern likes this.
  16. Wear it all the time. A serious new favorite. And it keeps bugs away.
  17. The more I read about Electric Sheep, the more I get a sense of it being a clone of the "Original" Rise(that is, when it began in the early 50's, not the one I have-athough there isn't TOO much of a difference).
  18. Do you know what a citronella candle smells like? It's that. With a little extra lemon thrown in.
  19. That description did it for me ... no desire ... at all. :sick007:
  20. It is utterly fantastic.

    It is probably a bit unfair to say it smells exactly like a bug candle. It isn't cloying at all. It has eucalyptus and lemon, and is actually very light. The aftershave dries down and mellows very fast, and somehow manages to keep a lemony thing going for quite some time.

    That said, I recommend to everyone to try a sample first. It seems like a definite love/hate thing.