I appreciate the intent to stick with what you know you enjoy. For me, that has turned into using up what I have and only replacing stuff with the 3 or 4 soaps that I enjoy most and fit into my definition of a good value. There are a few soaps I haven't tried that fit into that definition, but I'll try them one at a time as I run out of others, and preferably via samples. Over the past few years I've realized that with so many options available, you have to come up with your own ways of limiting choice. Otherwise you'll drive yourself crazy trying to choose, and even after the choice is made, wondering whether or not it was the wrong choice.