Maybe C&E Nomad. All the creams that are supposedly the best, Harris, Trumpers, etc... just don't work well for me.
I'm a soap man too, and although technically I've never tried this legendary opus to cool, I plan to correct this HUGE over-sight as quickly as possible, and I KNOW I'll reflect these EXACT SAME SENTIMENTS...) I'm thinking it could also be a great title for my next Jazz CD, what do you think JoAnna ?....With title credit given where credits due of course...
As a month old DE Wet Shaver, I am still experimenting. I like Col Conk Amber Soap. I have been using shave cream. Recently I got some Figaro' Shave Cream. I am really enjoy this cream. Lathers nicely and goes on thickly. I am open to trying other things too. That is the great thing about DE Wet Shaving you have so many exciting choices.
I haven't tried too many but I really like the Godrej(easy lather, nice scent), and I am enjoying Avalon Organics Peppermint(although I have orderd some Iced Sub Zero so this option could change)
Get some Arko creme! It is really top-notch. Just as good as Trumper's or TOBS, based on my experience. Bullgoose sells it at a good price.
My new favorite: ARKO Creams, especially (but not limited to) Arko Extra Sensitive. And this NOT just for the price (because it is lower-priced than many creams); this is would be just as good if the price were $15/tube. It really is excellent.
I've always liked the Tom's of Maine creams, but they've stopped making them. I also like Bigelow. Last Christmas, I got Speick shaving cream and I love it, especially the scent!