How Many Clubman Fragrances In Your Den?

Wow....I'll have to keep reading. I mean, I take your word for it, but I have read otherwise...time to compare those who, like you, say zero vs.those who say a lot.

 

Still none, zero, nada.

 

I never said that I have never owned a Clubman fragrance. The OP asked "how many Clubman fragrances in your den?"
As of 6/28/23, I have zero.

 

Let me say this....."OHHHHHHHHH Sorry". (Well, I just said it).

 

zero

Regular Clubman makes me gag.

The talc is the only thing I ever stockpiled, whenever I found it on clearance. Good stuff, that.

 

I used classic Pinaud Clubman (regular) today for the first time in about a month or so. It really is one of the best after shaves -- for me.
Also, to me, it is leaps and bounds above the other Pinauds I've used (the ones that actually say Pinaud Clubman on the bottle as opposed to, say, Lustray.)

Vanilla was a major disappointment. It smells like an after shave without any scent added. Special Reserve I liked more at first, now less so -- but at least it has a scent.

Lustray Spice is great if you're into the Old Spice scent -- which I am. To me, it is better than the current Old Spice.

Lustray Blue Spice is pretty good, too -- but the scent, to me, is not a variant of Spice -- it is completely different.

Well, there's my 2 scents!

 

The only Clubman I would tolerate in my den.

 

The pwer of suggestion...I liked it more before I read people's negative comments on it.
I usually cut it with Witch Hazel 50/50 now.
I use it straight before I watch a Clint Eastwood or Charles Bronson movie.

 

Not a Clubman, but, to me, Stephan Spicey is the same to me. I don't detect a scent. I can't tell the difference between the 2.

 

Try applying your amount into fairly wet palms, then splash.

 

The one without Witch Hazel, right?

 

yes

 

Just kidding, Frag Daddy. I couldn't pass up a good cartoon opportunity.​

 

update.
lime sec,citrus musk,original,vanilla,special reserve,whiskey woods,gent's gin,virgin island bay rum.various talcs,

 

the col conk bay rum is very similar.

 

Still none, but I am considering repurchasing a Special Reserve...

 

Ok. Going from memory.

Pinaud Clubman
Lime Sec
Citrus Musk
Virgin Island Bay Rum
Classic Vanilla
Special Reserve

 

Pinaud Clubman
Lime Sec
Osage
Special Reserve

 

Well, I just introduced a vintage bottle of Lilac Vegetal back in my den. That makes a total of...one.

 

Well, if you weren’t already living in the dog house…



Poor Fido!