I keep being drawn to Old Spice. I really wish they'd go back to the Shulton formula and bring back the glass bottle. I don't recall the fresh lime scent...wish it was still around.
Having tried many aftershaves over the years, the one I will always keep as a staple is the TSD Sensitive splash. It does a great job with just a bit of the alcohol bite. It is truly scent-free and therefore will not interefere with any cologne I am using. Really great stuff!
Tough call, choosing between two Clubman scents, but I most definitely go with the Bay Rum, then the Clubman.