Discussion in 'Shave Soaps' started by DaltonGang, Nov 28, 2016.
Toughest for me. Should have made that clear.
You need one more choice. That would be neither one.
Ok, people like those Desert Island hypotheticals. So if you were deserted, with only those two, which would you choose?? Silly, I know.
Arko shave stick all the way babe, far less hassle than Williams Mug, when the soap fades away pretty quickly for some people who still have problems with Williams Mug.
Because Arko always wins over Williams Mug, the voting polls speak for itself
Having used both Arko and modern Williams.......Arko winds hands down, in fact it's the only soap I use regularly.
O.K. I'd take Williams. Preferably old Williams. It would take a lot of the new stuff a puck every 2 weeks but I could use it. Arko is hard on my face so I'd need a balm. Vintage Williams and I'm good to go.
I'm 100% positive that if the Williams Top Holder Shave Stick in it's original formula were still around, it would be way above Arko in the numbers...
The people making Williams have to be brain dead. I remember the menthol version and I think I read about a rose version but don't remember it personally. Locally the only 2 soaps available are Williams and VdH. I guess if you have a captive market why change.
I've never had the opportunity to use vintage Williams. I wish they would make it again as I've heard many good things about it . But as for the new Williams and VDH, I'd rather VDH.
i know its not on the list gents but wilkinson sword stick for me ..as good as arko with a nice scent..to me ..
1 picked Arko , not only is it a great soap, shaved and pressed into a bowl but because Williams has greatly diminished since I first started using it in 1962. Arko is far superior now, except if I was able to get vintage, then I'd consider them about equal except for scents
I like ARKO, so cheap and smells like a gas station bathroom's powered soap from the 60's-70's (Boraxo lemon smell, I think)... not a bad thing, just weird memories. ARKO has a particular following within the straight razor guys for its slickness. I'm good with it but my brother gets severe irritation with the soap itself, a rash that resembles poison ivy. Did I mention inexpensive? Buy it in bulk on Amazon.
I was gifted one of these a few weeks back. It is an amazing shave stick!!
I know I saw. The one you were gifted is the newer U.S. one... Not sure if any different in formula, but the one you have I think is scented with rose. The two I have are older and have no scent other than a vintage tallow soap. I think it smells like black pepper, while my wife just thinks it smells like soap. If yours performs that well, I'm guessing they just added the scent, and it may be the same formula, or maybe improved.
No scent other then soap. Just like the vintage cake of Williams. Where was yours made??
Both of mine were made in Gastonbury Connecticut, so definitely pre 60s. Based on advertising that I've seen for the metal Williams Top Holders, I'd also venture that they are pre 30s.
Awesome. Thanks for sharing!
Separate names with a comma.