Typically after I shave it's a cold water rinse, maybe a splash of witch hazel if there are nicks/weepers. If it's a cut (because at 45 I still do that) or more than a couple of weepers, I'll hit with the alum block. However, I'm wondering as far as actual aftershave if I'm screwing it up. My "go to" is the Pinaud clubman, I like the scent and feel of it with the added bonus it's easy to get and cheap. But the alcohol makes skin a little dry at times. I picked up some of the Pacific Shaving caffeinated lotion and have used that. I think it works great but I've missed the "Pinaud effect" so to speak, so I have started using the Pinaud 1st and after a little while follow-up with the lotion. I guess I'm trying to go for the best of both worlds, to be honest. Question is, does this make sense or have I gone full potato? Does anyone else do anything along these lines? Maybe use some classic Nivea cream from the blue tin after the AS? Thanks in advance.