I started with creams and still prefer them to soaps. I think most soaps lack the richness and deep scent that most creams have.
Thanks guys. I think you're pointing me in the right direction and they sound like great recommendations. I have some homework to do this weekend on some of these soaps... Tabac, Stirling, TOBS, TSD, Mikes, Mitchell's Wool Fat...
I just ordered some lemon glacial and orange chill from Stirling. I think that will satisfy my menthol fix.