London Barbershop is more of aquatic cologne type barbershop scents such as: Mickey Lee Kraken, Mikes Natural Barbershop, Fine American Blend. While Clubman is more powdery slightly floral type, mostly associated with Barbershop scents since barbers have been using it for decades.
I love the scent of Pinaud Clubman aftershave and would love to be able to shave with the same scent. Do you use the soap or the cream? And do they both smell like the aftershave?
The Clubman website(Clubmanonline), shows us the various creams to use prior to the aftershave. In fact, I might have another go at the canned cream in the near future.
I was going to say "Anyway....back to Stoylin"..but I was the one who took us off topic in the first place(chuk yuk yuk)
I use Stirling BS plus 4 other of their soaps. I find Stirling one of the slickest soaps out there. Excellent customer service too.