I've yet to try any shave soaps, but for Witch Hazel and Aloe I love the Vetiver. I plan on trying the soaps eventually, like when I need soaps, which may be a few years.
They sell very, very large samples as cheap as dirt. Buy several and I guarantee you’ll find something you like that’ll last you a month. Add a couple of tins to your order to put the samples you like best in. Best value in shaving, bar none.
Y'know, just from sniffing my AGAR sampler, I have the slight feeling it could win me over as Sandpiper did. I do have a tough choice from these 4, but I wouldn't be surprised if Agar tops the list, and I'll have to have ANOTHER choice....from the remaining 3.