I grated up the Palmolive shave stick to occupy new OS mug. It gets lots of praise on the forums and is an exceptional value, outside of the states. I also broke down and placed an order with TSD, A couple of SOAPS and the Wheat SC I've been wanting to try. 1st impressions of the Palmolive are good, it would be better if it wasn't so expensive stateside.

Well, I broke down and finally ordered one of the newer RazoRock tallow soaps, Napoleon's Violet to be exact.

Maybe give them a look, they're not that expensive at all.

I'm a tallow guy myself and your list is about the same as mine for fav's. That being said, I got several TOBS products for Father's Day this year and have been working my way through the pile. These bucket-o-creams from TOBS aren't bad. I face lather and pile it on with good results sofar. I can also recommend ARKO creams. Bare in mind that none fo these are tallow based.

BTW, aint it grand how well a Tabac puck fits in an OS mug?

I have to shave a fine edge off Tabac and MWF to get them to fit. But they certainly fill up the mug nicely.