Krampert's Finest Acadian Spice bay rum Speick Art of Shaving Sandalwood California Antilles Trading Company's Dominica Bay Rum Maybe they became unavailable?
Love seeing some of these old threads resurrected and reading how the community answers fluctuate (or remain completely constant). Still seems like Clubman and the Shulton Old Spice get a few nods. Both are in my favorites. I also am a fan of the bourbon vanilla from TSD as well as the Iced SubZero. @Queen of Blades makes some excellent aftershaves!