I remember a similar thread and poll to this from a while back. Simply, what element in your shave do you labor over or debate the most? For me it is soap. I have several soaps and enjoy all of them. It's a tough decision to determine what to use. What about for you?
Only razors. One brush, half dozen soaps, about 30 razors in rotation. Sent from my Nexus 5X using Tapatalk
It's almost a toss-up for me between soap/cream or after shaves. I voted for after shaves though. I like to pair AS splashes with whatever soap I use that day. And as I have a few splashes that go well with particular soaps, that's usually my challenge in deciding.
Since I only have four razors, and you can only use one at a time(tho I bet there are some psych...er, Gents who try the old one in each hand trick around here), the blade/razor thing is a nonstarter. Creams/Soaps is another deal altogether. Usually I'm thinking about what one I'll be using the next day right after today's shave.
Razors! Without a doubt, razors! Between all of my DEs, SEs, injectors and SRs, it's always a tough decision.
Soap for me. I only have two brushes at the moment, so I alternate them. If I have time, I use my straight, otherwise just grab whatever calls me, and the aftershave is mostly determined by the soap I use.
Most of my AD's have diminished greatly. I regularly use one preshave, one soap, two 3 piece DE razors, two blades, one aftershave balm. The only choice I have to make is which aftershave I want to use.
I don't decide till the day I use them and then until I actually go shave. And I still spend time on all the products, so I agree with @Primotenore and @Boojum1, for me, all of them.
I didn't vote. Under "normal" circumstances I'd be Focusing on a particular razor. Instead I'm working my way through 30+ soap samples. Type of soap usually dictates brush type but I'm face lathering instead of using a bowl. Matching aftershaves is right out. Everything is all flibbertigibbet; A.K.A - S.O.P.
I only have stuff that I really enjoy using so it doesn't take a lot of time to decide which one, using any of them will do.
I pick out which razors I'm going to use a month at a time and my soaps and brushes are in a set rotation so I think aftershave is the one that I toil over most, especially now that I've been getting a few more options.