Worst-Smelling Aftershave in Your Opinion?

Discussion in 'Preshave and Aftershave' started by boyextraordinare, Oct 19, 2009.

  1. boyextraordinare

    boyextraordinare New Member

    At present, I can't think of one AS whose scent I don't find appealing, save one:

    AV Musk
    - it's simply disastrous! :sick007

    Which ASs do you folks find most vile?

    This is the only one I truly can't stand - it literally makes me nauseous. I formerly didn't like Skin Bracer Green, then began to love it, so who knows...
  2. HBK42581

    HBK42581 Member

    I actually like AV Musk. Jeris Musk, on the other hand, is truly a putrid smell. I bought some from ebarbershop and hoped that maybe it wasn't as bad as most have said, but it was. I tossed it out.
  3. ChemErik

    ChemErik Mr. Personality

    Herban Cowboy! They have a couple equally horrible scents.
  4. Duckster

    Duckster Wabbit Season!

    I love AV Musk.

    The worst for me are Pinaud Clubman :sick007 and Pinaud Lilac Vegitol :sick007
  5. Zach

    Zach New Member

    Great idea for a thread.
    I am olfactorially challenged, so I asked the wife.
    She doesn't like any Vetiver at all, and she doesn't like the Clubman Lime Sec, which smells like Pledge to her.
  6. Dewaine

    Dewaine Well-Known Member

    This should be interesting, because I think most scents are unappealing (or less appealing) the first time they are encountered.
  7. Michaelshane

    Michaelshane New Member

    I hate old spice....:sick007
  8. crackstar

    crackstar Israeli Ambassador to TSD

    The worst smelling aftershave to me is Stetson--I cannot bear it. :(
  9. Zach

    Zach New Member

    That's like saying "I hate pizza" :D
    Switchermike, jeraldgordon and BamaT like this.
  10. crackstar

    crackstar Israeli Ambassador to TSD

    And I LOVE pizza! :happy102
    Switchermike likes this.
  11. Michaelshane

    Michaelshane New Member

    I hate Old Spice and pizza.....:D

    Especially together.
    Switchermike likes this.
  12. boyextraordinare

    boyextraordinare New Member

    I've never met a man who doesn't like Old Spice.

    AV Blue is very nice in my book, while others dislike it - but OLD SPICE??!
  13. Will

    Will Nevermind

    Old Spice, really?

    I actually have not found one I did not like..... well I am not wild about Musgo Real.
  14. ChemErik

    ChemErik Mr. Personality

    Interesting all the Old Spice love. I find it rather middle of the road and the wife can't stand it. But, I think for her it brings up bad memories, so it might not be the scent itself.
  15. CSBudzi

    CSBudzi Member

    And I have never met a women that loved it. Most of the time I hear women describe it as "Okay" but just as often I hear women say it's disgusting, a headache in a bottle. I'm sure there are some woman that like it, but I doubt there are any that prefer oldspice to anything else.
    I think Oldspice is not so good in the scent depot.
  16. Michaelshane

    Michaelshane New Member

    I don't like anything that has the old fashioned barbershop smell.
  17. Infotech

    Infotech Active Member

    Skin Bracer Burnished Leather - It was discontinued for a reason. It smells like an old wet baseball glove that has had time to mildew.

    Current stuff - Pinaud Clubman just beats out every other splash in the shave isle at your local CVS, but they aren't far behind..
  18. techni

    techni New Member

    Floid, awful stuff.
  19. crackstar

    crackstar Israeli Ambassador to TSD

    I love Floid Classic--great scent, with lots of menthol.
  20. BullGoose

    BullGoose Well-Known Member

    The Drugstore brand English Leather (not to be confused with Spanish Leather) aftershave was nauseating. Brut was pretty nasty as well. Of course, YMMV

Share This Page