Clubman S.R. has at least one saving grace, to my nose anyway: it has a note that evokes a pipe tobacco-y vibe that few others frags do...pipe tobacco being a scent that's definite and amorphous at the same time, lots of guys look for but is hard to track down precisely. It's about the only Clubman I'd have on my shelf but I'm out and it's too much trouble to replace. I would not have put it in quite the same category as Aramis, but I can see a very, very distant similarity. To me it's much closer to Halston Z-14 or Coty's cheap but very nice (and extinct) Wild Woods. Both of these I have; true, neither is an a/s but they're similar enough that I don't have a need to obtain more S.R., though I'd snag it if I found it cheap. Your nose, as always, may vary.