Your after shave stash

Pinaud VI Bay Rum
Pinaud Clubman
Fine American Blend
Old Spice Classic
Nivea ASB Sensitive
Dapper's Not Dead Lime

And soon...THE VEG.

 

I'm pretty boring with my selections. Here are what I have now in order of preferred use (but I rotate about once a week):

Ogallala Bay Rum
Captain's Choice Cat O' Nine Tails
Old Spice Classic
Old Spice Sport
Proraso Green
Aqua Velva Musk

 

that's not boring. looks as if you got the bases covered, with a lot less clutter than my mess.
I've got seventeen grandkids who know I like to smell nice.

 

I guess I'll keep this to full sized bottles as I am a big believer in samples. I Have samples out the yingyang.

Fine L'Orange Noir
Fine American
Old Spice
Brut
Jeri's Osage Rub
Florida Water
Ogallala BR Limes and Peppercorns
Pinaud Clubman
(Added 2/16) Imperial Bergamot and Booster Aquarius.


On the way:
Clubman Musk
Barbon

 

It's a fine line between collecting and hoarding….

 

Here's my list. It's been stagnant for months, except for receiving the Fine American as a Christmas gift.

Aftershaves -
* AV Ice Blue
* CVS Old Spice
* Mennen Skin Bracer
* Clubman
* Clubman SR
* Osage Rub
* Fine American Blend
* Ogallala Bay Rum, Limes, & Peppercorns
* Speick
* Floid SE Mentolado Vigoroso
* TSD Iced SubZero
* Homemade mix

Colognes -
* Kenneth Cole Signature
* Paul Sebastian
* Tommy Hilfiger

Witch Hazels -
* Stirling Lemon Chill WH
* Thayer's Cucumber WH

Balm -
* Nivea Men Sensitive PSB

 

had a friend gift an antique pinaud bottle with a bottle of The Veg. Have to say enjoying Fine family the most now: American, Platinum, fresh vetiver, and l'orange noir. Will always keep a bottle of Nivea balm, and Clubman. There's also a bottle of Florida Water that will not be purchased again. Almost forgot the AOS Lavender.

 

It would seem that my preference is for vintage Old Spice. I'm just an Old Spice junkie. Reminds me of my dad.

Armani Mania cologne
4711 cologne
TOBS Luxury AS
Old Spice Lime original Shulton AS Frosted Glass 1960s
Old Spice Lime original Shulton cologne Frosted Glass 1960s
Old Spice original Shulton red plastic Body Talc 1960 - 1968 (gift from my father in law)
Old Spice original Shulton AS Travel 1973 - 1975 (gift from my father in law)
Old Spice original Shulton 1973 glass cologne Stopper #3
Old Spice original Shulton 1973 glass cologne Stopper #4
Old Spice original Shulton 1973 - 1975 Blue Ship Decanter AS
Old Spice original Shulton 1973 - 1975 Lantern Decanter AS
Old Spice original Shulton 1980 glass AS (gift from my father in law)
Old Spice original Shulton 1956 glass Talcum powder (gift from my father in law)
Old Spice original Shulton 1983 Porcelain Sail Boat
Vintage Avon 1981 California Perfume Co. Anniversary Bay Rum
Vintage Avon Trazarry AS
Vintage Avon Mesmerize cologne
Halston Z-14 cologne
Florida Water cologne
Pinaud Clubman AS
Pinaud Clubman Virgin Island Bay Rum
Old Spice original Shulton 1947 glass Talcum powder (ship Mt. Vernon sailing to right)
Tommy Bahamas St. Barts cologne

 

that's a lot of after shave. you should open up a store lol. im still new to wet shaving but I can see how a large collection can get built. so much to choose from. I ordered a bottle of the clubman bay rum but I couldn't smell it before I ordered it. how is it? I know different companies make bay rum differently

 

If you've only got one bay rum in your den, its not a bad one to have.

 

Avon (all 1960s- early '80s)
Leather
Excalibur
Imperator
Blue Blazer
Deep Woods
Brisk Spice
Windjammer
Island Lime
Light Musk
Structured set (Steel, Glass, Wood)

Stanley Home Products (Amway) Points North ('70s?)
English Leather ('70s)
E.L. Timberline (same)
Roman Brio ('70s)
BRUT! (Dollar General)
AV Musk
Skin Bracer (current)
Sportsman cologne ('50s-'60s)
Burma Bey ('60s)
Denim ('70s-'80s)
Men's Choice Spice and Arctic Blue ($ store)
Avery Men's Stock pine tree in a bottle
Lucky Tiger lotion
Mentholated/alum'd Witch Hazel


Plus several colognes/EdTs.

 

It's from the clove-y side of the BR family tree, plus cinnamon (I think). Guys either love that or hate it.

 

Pretty boring here also:
Skin Bracer (work day go to AS)
Old Spice (The old stuff, for when out with the Mrs)

Might try to brew up some Bay Rum this spring just to see if I can.

 

I am slowly building my collection. Pretty small compared to several on here but here it goes:

Stirling bay rum
Captain's Choice bay rum
Clubman bay rum
Clubman
Clubman Vanilla
Tabac
TOBS Sandlewood
Florida water
Osage Rub
Proraso eucalyptus and menthol
Aqua Velasquez Ice Blue

 

Interesting. I have as many razors as you have aftershaves, and as many aftershaves as you have razors.

 

If I beg whimper and groval Would you make some of your World Famous

• Black River bay rum (home made) and send it to me?

 

A picture is easier



Dave

 

Glad to hear you like the PS aftershave. I haven't tried it. Assuming that you have tried PS shaving soap, can you give me a clue as to how the 2 work together? Also, does the PS aftershave have a talc feeling and smell as the shaving soap does?

 

Actually I haven't tried the PS soap so I can't compare the two.
If you've ever used Lucky Tiger the post-shave moisturizing/skin feel is very, very similar to what I get from Lucky Tiger.
The scent is very subtle. I know it's branded 'Green Tea' but I wouldn't be able to describe it apart from 'subtle and rather pleasing'.
I absolutely use it more for how it feels rather than how it smells

 

I'd be happy to, Patrick, but regrettably the ATF frowns seriously upon the transference of homemade alcoholic substances...