Your after shave stash

Here's what I use:

Bloc Osma Alum Block
Thayers Lavender Witch Hazel
African Skin Solutions Unrefined Shea Butter
Nivea Sensitive Post-Shave Balm
Alt Innsbruck
Floid Vigoroso
Pinaud Clubman

And I've got these but have not tried them yet:

The Body Shop Maca Root Razor Relief
Geo F. Trumper Coral Skin Food

And of course, this is my long-time juice that I still use:

Mennen Afta Pre-electric :ahem:

 

My List:

Floid Blue
Booster Polar Ice
Fine American Blend
Aqua Velva Ice Blue
Aqua Velva Sport
Aqua Velva Musk
Old Spice
Gillette Intense Cooling
Adidas sport
CC Bay Rum
CC CONT
TOBS Bay Rum
Lucky Tiger Bay Rum
Ogallala Bay Rum limes & peppercorns
HTGAM Bay Rum
Anthony Gold Red Cedar
Proraso
Myrsol Plastic Shave
Osage Rub
Clubman
Lilac Vegital
Clubman VIBR
Col Conk Bay Rum
Kramperts Finest Acadian Spice Bay Rum

 

Looks like you really like your Bay Rum. Which one do you like best?

 

If I could pick two it would be the Ogallala for the scent and CC for the burn(both of which I like). I dont think Ive found "the one" yet.

 

Damn, definitely don't have the aftershave diversity you guys have! I have the ubiquitous clubman, and then I have a tube of Boucheron which is a nice mild scent, but it lasts a long time.

 

Here's my modest stash:
Proraso green
Pino Silvestre
Pitralon Classic
Ralon
Bello Bay Rum
Bello Bay Rum & Lime

 

Let me see.

1. Fine American Blend.
2. Krampert's Frostbite.
3. CC Bay Rum.
4. CC Lime.
5. Barbon.
6. Myrsol Emulsion.
7. Dickinson Witch Hazel.
8. Stirling Lemon Chill Witch Hazel.
9. Razorock by Fine XXX Limited Edition.
10. Aqua Velva Ice Blue.
11.

 

Aqua Velva Ice Blue
Truefitt and Hill Trafalgar
Proraso Green Balm
ToBS Victorian Limes
Pre de Provence

 

Old Spice Classic
Grey Flannel
Preferred Stock
Stetson Original
Captain's Choice Cat O' Nine Tails *
Captain's Choice Bay Rum*
Captain's Choice Lime*
Captain's Choice North*
Captain's Choice Sandalwood
Avon His Story Cologne
Avon Perceive Cologne
Avon Prospect Cologne
Avon Wild Country Outback Cologne
Avon Mesmerize for Men A/S
Avon Mesmerize for Men Cologne
Avon Black Suede for Men A/S
Avon Black Suede for Men Cologne
Brut Classic
Mennen Skin Bracer Original *
Aqua Velva Classic Blue Ice *
Aqua Velva Musk *
Stirling Soap Co. Coniferous *
Stirling Soap Co. Bay Laurel *
Stirling Soap Co. Ben Franklin
Stirling Glacial Lemon Chill *
Stirling Margaritas in the Arctic

 

Out of all of those I've only tried the Stirling Coniferous and the Bay Laurel. I really did like the Coniferous after first being a bit on the fence about it.

 

Most of these I got from my Father in law when he passed away. And most of the Avon A/S and Colognes I have had for a long time, one I got when my wife ordered Avon over the years.

 

Well maybe if i drive up to your neighborhood and buy you a cup of coffee I might ask for some.

Might be cheaper to just get your recipe and make it myself

 

As much as I'd enjoy the visit, Patrick, I do think you'd enjoy the process of making your own Bay Rum. All it really takes is a few key ingredients, some time and voila!….

 

If I mix in some #2 Diesel, will it smell the same?

 

In no particular order:

After Shaves:
Pinaud Clubman
Pinaud Classic Vanilla
Pinaud VIBR
Pinaud Citrus Musk
Aqua Velva Ice Blue
Aqua Velva Musk
Barbasol Pacific Rush
Old Spice
Fine American Blend
Cool Water

After Shave Balm:
Nivea Senitive
True Gentlemen (unscented)
British Sterling
Real Shaving Co

Witch Hazel: Dickinson's

Alum: Osma Bloc

 

I do love the aftershaves but I limit myself to 5-6 at a time otherwise I would get out of control. Here's the current line up
- Pinaud Lilac Vegetal.
- Gabel's Bay Rum
- Gabel's Lilac
- Gabel's Stay Cool
- Jeris Musk
- Aveeno Fragrance Free aftershave lotion ( I use this after using the alcohol based splash, if I need a moisturizer.

I really like both of the lilac scents, even though they are quite different.

The bay rum is nice, no added scents (clove, cinnamon etc, just straight spicy bay rum).

 

So far all I have is AOS lavender post shave balm and Witchazel I spiked with tea tree oil, lime and eucalyptus essential oils

I noticed a few of you have a lime and peppercorn listed, can someone desribe that? Anyone know It's there a brick and mortar store that might sell it So I could smell it before buying it?

 

I just received Clubman - Vanilla today and really like the scent. I've been wanting to try it for quite a long time and finally pulled the trigger and ordered it. I'm very glad I did. It still has the barbershop scent but a little more upscale and refined than regular Clubman.

 

I'm nowhere in the running with these lists. Heavens to Bettsy some are as long as War and Peace. Anyhow I've only been a DE razor fella for three years and my shorty list is this:
Shulton Old Spice AS and Cologne (way back vintage)
Old Spice Burley
Old Spice Fresh Lime (India)
Adidas edt
Umbro edt
FCUK edt

Old Spice AS balm
Mount Purious Jojoba oil (spiked with a touch of, yes you've already guessed, Old Stuff)

Talcs
Old Spice (Shulton)
Old Spice Burley
Pinaud Clubman

Yes It's a short one but happy going old school. Cuz old's cool!

 

Asma Alum Block
Aqua Velva Ice Blue*
Barbasol Brisk
Dickinson's Witch Hazel
Family Dollar Old Spice
Mennen Skin Bracer
Pinaud Classic Vanilla
Pinaud Clubman*
Pinaud Lilac Vegetal
Thayers Cucumber Witch Hazel
Thayers Lemon Witch Hazel
Thayers Rose Petal Witch Hazel