Your after shave stash

Old Spice
Florida Water
Boots Freshwater
Tabac
Pinaud Clubman Original
Humphreys Citrus Witch Hazel
Hai Karate
Aqua Velva
Blue Stratos
Brut
Lavenda Cologne
Fine L'orange
Fine American Blend
Quorum EDT
Topman Vetiver EDT
Top man No 27 EDT
Citrus & Wood EDT
Rapport EDT
David Beckham Pour Homme
Joop Go EDT
Selin Lemon Cologne
Accolado Glacial
TSD Coconut & Lime Sample

 

Top three if you had to pick?

 

If I had to pick three

Love Florida Water. Very cheap and a long lasting spiced orange smell.
Love it

Quorum. Old School manly smell
Bold and strong. Long lasting and again cheap to buy

Yardley Citrus & Wood
Amazing cedarwood smell
Very similar if not identical to the scent from St James of London shaving cream - Cedarwood and clarysage for anyone that has used it
Great Stuff.

Also got Halston Z-14 onroute.
Not had a whiff yet and buying blind but supposed to be another bold strong smell.

 

The Thayer's Cucumber WH is great. I've been out for a while and need to get some.

 

I'll categorize my arsenal by usage.

Frequently
Proraso Green
Spieck
Pinaud Clubman
Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum
Stetson Original
Barbasol Pacific Rush and Brisk
Klar
Fine (American Blend, Fresh Vetiver and Platinum)

Latest Purchase(s)
Colonel Conk Amber
Musgo Real
Floid Mentolado Vigoroso

Regular/Seasonal
Tabac
Alt Innsbruck
Greenbrier by Caswell-Massey
Royall Bay Rhum
Pinaud Musk
DR Harris Windsor

Only Used A Few Times
Captain's Choice North
Newport by Caswell-Massey
Number Six by Caswell-Massey
Royal Copenhagen
DR Harris Arlington
Taylor of Bond Street No. 74
Irisch Moos
Pinaud Lime Sec
Pinaud Citrus Musk
Skin Bracer
Aqua Velva
English Leather

Have Not Tried
Pinaud Reserve
Aqua Velva Musk

Don't Like
Taylor of Bond Street Eton College - This smelled like lighter fluid and really dried out my face.
Taylor of Bond Street Sandalwood - Had a decaying like odor.
Jockey Club by Caswell-Massey - Smells like English Leather to me. Also dried out my face.

Gel or Balm
Gillette White Balm
Afta Blue Label

 

Pinaud Clubman
Pinaud Vanilla
Lilac Vegetal
Figaro
Barbon
Aqua Velva Musk
Aqua Velva Ice Blue
Lucky Tiger Aspen
Florida Water
Pinaud Bay Rum
Old Spice
4711
Burt's Bees Bay Rum
Gillette Cool Splash
English Leather

 

Hmmm lets see.....

Splashes
4711
Aqua Velva - Frost Lime - vintage
Aqua Velva - Ice Blue
Aqua Velva - Ice Blue - vintage (light blue)
Aqua Velva - Ice Sport
Aqua Velva - Ice Sport - vintage
Aqua Velva - Musk
Aqua Velva - Redwood - vintage
Aqua Velva - Surf - vintage
Amway - Charter Club - vintage
Amway - Points North - vintage
Amway - Silver Surf - vintage
Amway - Tonga - vintage
Avon - Bay Rum - vintage
Avon - Blend 7 - vintage
Avon - Blue Blazer - vintage
Avon - Brisk Spice - vintage
Avon - Clint - vintage
Avon - Cool Sage - vintage
Avon - Deep Woods - vintage
Avon - Everest - vintage
Avon - Excalibur - vintage
Avon - Island Lime - vintage
Avon - Leather - vintage
Avon - Light Musk - vintage
Avon - Oland - vintage
Avon - Sea Zone - vintage
Avon - Spicy - vintage
Avon - Tai Winds - vintage
Avon - Tribute - vintage
Avon - Wild Country - modern
Avon - Wild Country - vintage
Avon - Windjammer - vintage
Barbasol - Brisk
Barbasol - Pacific Rush
Big Wheel - vintage
Blue Stratos
Booster - Iced Lime
Booster - Mosswood
Booster - Polar Ice
Bootlegger's - Bay Rum (Master BR/Clubman VIBR/Superior 70 BR)
Bootlegger's - Bay Rum Lime (BBR w/ Pinaud Citrus Musk)
Bootlegger's - El Dorado (Pinaud Special Reserve, Pinaud Classic Vanilla, & English Leather)
Bootlegger's - Perfecto (Master BR/Superior 70 BR/Vitos Colonia Tabacco)
Bootlegger's - Arctic Lime (Pinaud Lime Sec & Osage Rub)
Bootlegger's - Green Freeze (Skin Bracer & Osage Rub)
Brut
Brut - Attitude
Brut - Dominant
Captain's Choice - North
Captain's Choice - Sandalwood
Citrocol Lime
Columbia High Wheeler - Vintage (Fuller Brush Co.)
Dominca Bay Rum Lime
English Leather - modern
English Leather - vintage
English Leather Lime - vintage
Floid - Amber
Guerlain Vetiver - Vintage
Hai Karate - vintage
Ivy Club (Shulton's Old Spice clone)
Jade East - vintage
Mandom
Master - Bay Rum
Master - Lilac Vegetol
Matchabelli - Musk for Men - vintage
Myrsol Antesol
Nivea - Energy
Old Spice - Burley
Old Spice - Modern P&G
Old Spice - Vintage Shulton
Old Spice - Whitewater
Osage Rub
Pinaud Clubman - After Shave Lotion modern
Pinaud Clubman - After Shave Lotion vintage
Pinaud Clubman - Citrus Musk
Pinaud Clubman - Classic Vanilla
Pinaud Clubman - Lilac Vegetal
Pinaud Clubman - Lime Sec
Pinaud Clubman - Musk
Pinaud Clubman - Special Reserve
Pinaud Clubman - Virgin Island Bay Rum
Saint Charles Shave - Fairway
Saint Charles Shave - Woods
Skin Bracer - Italian
Skin Bracer - Modern
Skin Bracer - Vintage
Skin Bracer - Cooling Blue
Speick
Sportsman AS and Talc set - vintage
Superior 70 Bay Rum
Tabac
Vitos - Colonia Tabacco
Yardley - vintage

Balms
444
Afta - Fresh AS Conditioner
Afta - Original AS Conditioner
Avon - Mesmerize
Avon - Wild Country
Barbasol - Pacific Rush ASB
Burt's Bees Bay Rum ASB
Gillette Series After Shave Gel
Nivea Sensitive ASB
Myrsol Emulsion
Saint Charles Shave - Fairway

 

Holy cow
And, the obvious question, (and I know it's sometimes situational/contextual) but if you had to pick one favorite which one would it be?

 

I looked up the definition of ASAD in the dictionary and your avatar is all that is shown! Great selection.

 

Wow. Do you own an aftershave shop.
Where do you keep all of them. You have a great collection there. Which one is your favourite?

 

If forced, I could do a top 5:
Avon Tai Winds
Skin Bracer
Lilac Vegetal
Captains Choice North
Bootlegger's Bay Rum

Thanks!

No shop, I just love aftershave.
Most in my bathroom. Duplicates and collectibles scattered around.

 

Wow!

 

Not much here

Clubman Pinaud
Nivea Sensitive skin
G Trumpers Skin Food Sandalwood
Yohji Aftershave Balm
Fine Platinum-just got it, have not used it yet.

 

*ADDITIONS (pre NBJ of course)
Floid Blue eau de toilette
Floid Vigoroso
Floid Moderna
Myrsol formula C
Myrsol formula K
Myrsol aqua de limon
Myrsol aqua balsamica
Myrsol masaje antesol
Myrsol Metilsol
Myrsol blue
CC north
CC lime
Layrite No9 bay rum
Lucky Tiger aftershave/ face tonic
L'Occitane eav de bavx
Alt Innsbruck
Tabac eau de cologne

*Samples
Mondial Axolute homme
Royall lime
Royall rugby
Royall vetiver
Royall musk

*Balms
Myrsol emulsion
Truefitt and Hill No 10 aftershave cologne balm
Crabtree and Evelyn nomad
Body shop macca root
Body shop arber

 

for me it's
.Clubman Country Club
.Rise cooling balm
.Mennen Skin-Bracer
.Stephan Bay Rum
(will try others when my budget allows)

 

Hmmm...Let's see. In no particular order:

Splashes:
Floid Amber
Floid Blue
Royall Bay Rhum (vintage)
Clubman
The Veg
Old Spice (vintage)
Old Spice (current production)
Alt Innsbruck
Irish Moos
RazoRock XX
Speick
Fine American Blend
Fine Snakebite
Fine Platinum
Fine Clean Vetiver
Fine Fresh Vetiver
Fine L'Orange Noir
Lucido
Mandom
4711
Thayers WH AS

Balms (wintertime my skin gets VERY dry):
Speick
Irish Moos
Old Spice
OR: any splash with First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Cream, which I started using at the suggestion of my daughter who works at Sephora. Absolutely the best moisturizing cream I've ever used... http://www.sephora.com/ultra-repair-cream-intense-hydration-P248407?skuId=1217744

 

Royal Copenhagen; Brut; British Sterling; Canoe; Jovan Musk; English Leather; Pinaud Lilac; Pinaud Bay Rum; Pinaud Clubman; Mennen Skin Bracer; Mennen Afta; Aqua Velva Ice Blue; Aqua Velva Musk; Gillette Cool Wave; Gillette After Shave Lotion; Old Spice. Might get some Jade East, soon; in case I run-out of stock!

 

I am sending a couple of your lists to SWMBO, just so she can see that I am not that bad.

Favorite- Hands down:
Clubman with M-Bomb

In no order:
Pinuad Clubman
Maggard's Orange Menthol
The Holy Black Gunpowder Spice
Osage Rub
Aquavelva Classic Blue
The Shave Den Iced Yin Yang
Classic Avon Oland in Camper Special Bottle w/Talc
Gillette Aftershave Gell
Pacific Aftershave Company Caffinated Aftershave Balm
The Veg- (Getting rid of this one)
Aubrey Men's Stock North Woods

 

Since the above post, I have acquired a few more:
Irish Moose (yes, I know I spelled that incorrectly)
Chiseled Face Summer Storm
Chiseled Face Ghost town Barber
Alpa 378
Alpa Windsor
Floid Black
Fine Platinum

I have a few bottles enroute:
Mandom (Japan)
Adam (Czech Republic)
Diplomat in two varieties, Fresh and Classic (Czech Republic)

And these are on the to be acquired roster:
Pitralon (Germany)
Pitralon Polar
4711
Alt Innsbruck