1. My top pick is Mennen Skin Bracer.

    But being mentholated, I don't like to use it when it's really cold outside. For colder months, my top pick is:

    Bootlegger's Bay Rum.
    Richard Jackson likes this.
  2. Vintage Shulton Old Spice is far and away my number one choice, the blend from the 70's is the best of the best. I also really like the modern P&G version.
  3. :cool:
    I cry foul! Only one? Not fair..
    I'd have to choose Clubman, while I'm setting here slathered in VIBR
  4. Newbie here but I REALLY like Pre de Provance Balm. Leaves the skin nice and soft, smeels good and helps with the burn.
  5. I can't participate in this... I cannot pick one
  6. Balm = Arko Krem.
    Splash = RazoRock The Stallion.
  7. I'm really surprised to see mention of Arko ;)
    Kenny Ingram likes this.
  8. Vétiver de Guerlain Vintage.
  9. Pinuad Osage Rub
  10. Gonna go with Old Spice Original. I love that stuff.
  11. On a Speick Active kick but love the Tabac
  12. Just got a bottle of Tabac today. Its my new favorite
    Jasio78 likes this.
  13. When I explained to my barber that I began wet shaving, he informed me he had a few bottles of various Clubman he would give me. Got slightly used bottles of Original and Musk.

    Clubman Musk has taken center stage. It's really stout out of the bottle, but softens really well.

    SCORE!

    And thanks Charlie's Barber Shop, Aiken, SC for the awesome goodies.
  14. I love Old Spice and Clubman original but the favorite around the house is Stirling Sharp Dressed Man.
  15. Both the wife and I love the classic old school stuff! Clubman, AV Ice Blue & of course Old Spice. Takes us both back in time!
  16. Clubman is my desert island AS

    Nothing beats Veg though....
    dscaver likes this.
  17. Clubman
    NewellVW likes this.
  18. I've thought for some months now that Clubman original and Clubman vanilla
    were both very good and something I just had to have.
    While they are good and I like them very much, I recently acquired a bottle
    of Florida Water, and I may have to change my vote.

    Florida Water.jpg

    I was expecting something pretty strong, but I was wrong.
    It's mild. Citrus notes, and a nice balance of clove to go with them.
    Says it's for ladies as well as men, but it seems more of a man's scent to me.
    Not pricey, and my local Walgreen drug store keeps it in stock. :)
  19. This one is mostly unknown to you but Ralon is my #1 AS
    [​IMG]
  20. 1)Captain's Choice Cat O' Nine Tails
    2) Captain's Choice Bay Rum
    3) Captain's Choice Lime
    4) Captain's Choice North
    5) Captain's Choice Sandalwood

    When I have been a "Mean Little Kid" I use the Aqua Velva Blue Ice It's SWMbO favorite of all of the ones I have.

    Those are listed in SWMbO preferred order List.
    Douglas Carey likes this.